Corporate Personality and Damages for Loss Caused to a Third Party Company: Forthwell v Pontegadea (UKSC)

With its recent decision in Forthwell Ltd v Pontegadea UK Ltd [2026] UKSC 33, handed down on September 17, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom considered a particularly important issue of contract law: whether a contracting party can claim damages for loss suffered by a third party, and specifically by a company within the same group.


The case concerned the historic Rogano restaurant in Glasgow. Forthwell, the tenant of the property, had granted the use of the premises to its wholly-owned subsidiary, Lynnet Leisure, which operated the restaurant. Following severe flood and fire damage, the restaurant was unable to reopen, and Lynnet suffered a significant loss of profits. Forthwell sought to recover these losses from the landlord.

The Supreme Court dismissed the claim. It affirmed the general rule that a contracting party may recover damages for its own loss and not, in principle, for loss suffered by a third party. The Court declined to create a new, broader exception that would allow a parent company to claim losses sustained by its subsidiary, holding that such an exception would be vague and difficult to apply.

Of particular significance is the Court's observation that the separate legal personality of companies carries real legal consequences. Forthwell and Lynnet had chosen to structure their business activities through two separate corporate entities and could not, after the fact, bypass the consequences of that choice.

The decision is therefore of particular interest to corporate and contract law, especially in cases involving corporate groups, commercial leases, and claims for loss of profits. At the same time, it serves as a reminder that corporate personality is not merely a protective mechanism, but can also directly affect the scope of available contractual remedies. (source: UK Supreme Court/photo pixabay.com)

Read more about the Decision here

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ombudsman inquiry on Commission President’s text messages is a wake-up call for EU

Legal Professional Privilege in the Digital Age: Recent case law of the ECtHR and the core principles that should govern searches

Questioning Suspects Without a Lawyer: Hungary and Czech Republic Infringed EU Law (CJEU)

Judges’ Freedom of Expression and the Limits of Disciplinary Power: The ECtHR Judgment in Savvas v. Greece

Motor vehicle liability insurance: EU law does not preclude the transfer of a claim for compensation held against an insurance company (CJEU)

Balancing Crime Control and Ne Bis In Idem: ECtHR Finds No Violation in Successive Proceedings

Obligation for lawyers to appear in person before disciplinary bodies : Advisory Opinion by ECtHR